Heilbronn »Eagle« in an incised clipped edges cartouche = around 1810?
Hello Top Cat
To date your large spoon in an early period of Georg Peter Bruckmann is only my subjective interpretation of marks = warden marks and maker’s marks I’ve seen, or I own, or I’ve made my own notices there fore (of seen
date engravings).
The old German town and warden marks, and maker’s marks guide, popularly called »
Rosenberg«, has, based on research results of
G. Pazaurek, published in
1912, registered in the 3rd edition, volume II, page 160, nr.
2534: Heilbronn warden mark »
HB« =
early XVIII century; nr.
2535: fineness mark »
13«
[similar as yours] (13 Lot = 812.5-1,000) =
XIX century.
In the 3rd edition, volume II, page 161, nr.
2542 is a very
brief history on [Georg]
Peter Bruckmann; nr. 2543, and nr. 2544 documentation (printed collection of by Georg Peter Bruckmann available appliqué).
In the 3rd edition, volume II, page 162, nr.
2545, and nr.
2546 examples of signage as maker’s mark the by »Theoderich« first shown incise eagle (looking, in terms of heraldry, to the “right”); there the example is dated
1846.
In the 3rd edition, volume II, page 162, nr.
2547, and nr.
2548 examples of signage as maker’s mark the
on your spoon shown eagle, in an incised clipped edges cartouche (looking, in terms of heraldry, to the “left”);
not dated.
For final is there in the 3rd edition, volume II, page 162, nr.
2549 as maker’s mark of »
P. Bruckmann & Söhne« [= very long before 1850; 1850 Georg Peter Bruckmann has died] described an »Adler« (»Eagle«); dated:
1902, or earlier.
My own examples, e.g. the
miniskirt »
Angel of Peace«
spoon is by engraving
dated 1821, has as fineness mark a »
13.« in an oval, as maker’s mark »
P:B&C«, and as “second maker’s mark” (?) the Heilbronn »Eagle« (looking, in terms of heraldry, to the “right”), in an incised circular cartouche;
see there fore the following picture:
Now I explain you, why I guess that there must be hold in mind also some doubts on »
R3« (»Rosenberg, 3rd edition«) and
Gustav Pazaurek’s examples:
Georg Peter Bruckmann was, and that could be said with complete certainty (!),
an experienced and famous steel die engraver!
Would somebody as he was engrave the
letters of his maker’s marks
with correctness — and engrave his in »
R3« (and by
G. Pazaurek) stated “
second maker’s mark” like as a “
first week apprentice”? The »
Eagle« like as a »
show-up cock«!
No, no, no!
That the “maker’s mark” of »
P. Bruckmann & Söhne« [= very long before 1850; 1850 Georg Peter Bruckmann has died] described as an »Adler« (»Eagle«), must be
dated 1902, or earlier?
A similar mark, as here above is mentioned, you could already see on the stems backside of the miniskirt »
Angel of Peace« spoon.
But that spoon is dated by engraving: »
1821.«
If you look to this example of an »
Eagle« - isn’t he not more “elegant” as the other “cock’s”?
Well, it’s my own theory, and very subjective interpretation:
The Heilbronn »
HP« warden mark of
mid XVII century, and »
HB« warden mark of
early XVIII century, were followed up by the, from me disrespectful baptized Heilbronn “cock’s”.
Georg Peter Bruckmann was then after 1805 in his first own professional phase — and, as I remember, started 1810 (maybe already earlier?) with the professional steel die engravings and production of his offer of appliqué.
He wasn’t warden — maybe never?
Could it not be happen, that once the Heilbronn “cocks” were
worn, the Heilbronn Guild has
requested Georg Peter Bruckmann
to engrave new warden marks, for to could replace the old and worn ones?
Later, when the Heilbronn Guild was in decline, and has ceased, Georg Peter Bruckmann adopted the Heilbronn »
Eagle« (in a circular cartouche) to be
company’s mark of »
Peter Bruckmann & Söhne«
?
This kind of adaptation has often happen in Germany — as I’ve observed until yet (well without a sounded research [because I’m not a historian; I’m a designer]), the Guild’s symbol has got almost the most respected member of a Guild as his future maker's mark.
By the way, you would be wonder, how many versions of the »
Bruckmann Eagle« in reality are existing.
Here you could find the source of »
R3«:
Volume I:
http://diglit.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/digl ... erg1922bd1" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Volume II:
http://diglit.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/digl ... berg1922ga" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Volume III:
http://diglit.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/digl ... erg1925bd3" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;
Well, only by sounded research could yours spoon be dated more exactly as my very subjective guess.
Maybe in the already mentioned catalogue »Silber aus Heilbronn für die Welt« is there fore a sounded explanation?
My catalogue is fare away, some where.
Kind regards silverport