Page 1 of 1

Brandy bowl with pseudo mark?

Posted: Wed Aug 23, 2023 8:26 am
by GiulyF
Dear all, but I mainly turn to @Oel
I'm undecided whether it is a Dutch or a German artifact, I'm triyng to identify two marks on a silver-gilt brandy bowl, town mark or the pseudo lion rampant for the fineness is partially illegible while that of the silversmith bears the letters CL between an anchor?

Could someone help me to recognize the hallmarks?
Along the outer edge it bears writing that I tried to transcribe to translate and it should be like this ... although it seems to me to be in German rather than Dutch
<<Anno 1656 Octoberis abends zwischen 6 und 7 uhr Ǝst geboren Thomas Wachler genatern Ursula pongraß Zollerin witb? 999>>

thanks to all,

G.


Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image
Image

Re: Brandy bowl with pseudo mark?

Posted: Wed Aug 23, 2023 8:35 am
by GiulyF
seeing the assayer's line so thick and saw-like it's more German than Dutch

Re: Brandy bowl with pseudo mark?

Posted: Wed Aug 23, 2023 10:37 am
by oel
Hi,
I believe the text of the engraving to be in German and some words in Latin. In appearance and style the bowl looks German to me.
Anno 1656 Den 8 Octoberis Abends Zwischen 6 Und 7 uhr Ǝst Geboren Thomas Wachler Genater Ursula pongraß Zollerin Witib
In October 1656 in the evening between 6 and 7 o'clock is born Thomas Wachler at birth Ursula pongrass Zollerin Witib

Townmark a (double headed) eagle. Maker's mark C upside down anchor L
Let us wait for Theodrich to chime in.

Peter.

Re: Brandy bowl with pseudo mark?

Posted: Thu Aug 31, 2023 3:07 am
by GiulyF
oel wrote: Wed Aug 23, 2023 10:37 am Hi,
I believe the text of the engraving to be in German and some words in Latin. In appearance and style the bowl looks German to me.
Anno 1656 Den 8 Octoberis Abends Zwischen 6 Und 7 uhr Ǝst Geboren Thomas Wachler Genater Ursula pongraß Zollerin Witib
In October 1656 in the evening between 6 and 7 o'clock is born Thomas Wachler at birth Ursula pongrass Zollerin Witib

Townmark a (double headed) eagle. Maker's mark C upside down anchor L
Let us wait for Theodrich to chime in.

Peter.
Hy Oel and thank you for the reply, I wait for Theo feedback.

G.

Re: Brandy bowl with pseudo mark?

Posted: Fri Sep 01, 2023 2:34 pm
by Theoderich
In this case the book of M. Rosenberg³ p307+308 coulb be helpful.

The hallmark looks like #3392, the makersmark like 3398.
But we find on an auction an beaker with an other variation of the hallmark and makers mark.

The shell could be real, but I'm not sure.
Scheffler and Rosenberg name some objects with these marks. If one were to request images of the marks of these objects, one could certainly answer this question.

Re: Brandy bowl with pseudo mark?

Posted: Tue Sep 05, 2023 6:06 am
by GiulyF
Theoderich wrote: Fri Sep 01, 2023 2:34 pm In this case the book of M. Rosenberg³ p307+308 coulb be helpful.

The hallmark looks like #3392, the makersmark like 3398.
But we find on an auction an beaker with an other variation of the hallmark and makers mark.

The shell could be real, but I'm not sure.
Scheffler and Rosenberg name some objects with these marks. If one were to request images of the marks of these objects, one could certainly answer this question.
Hey Theo thank you as always...I checked on V.II of Rosenberg, and actually he registers it but does not identify the name of the silversmith for "CL", I I therefore imagine that Scheffler, having published his study almost 60 years later, investigated the attributions that had remained unknown until then..

Thank you Theo!