I'm a collector of vintage WMF German tableware, so I sometimes run into items claiming to be 3rd Reich. I fully realize most 3rd Reich tableware on the market is fraudulent and, as I'm not a 3rd Reich collector, per se, I usually give such items a wide birth. Still, I'm curious from an historical perspective which, if any, WMF patterns/pieces could legitimately have been produced for 3rd Reich individuals or organizations. So...
I'm wondering what is your opinion of the book by James A. Yannes (2011), The Collector's Guide to 3rd Reich Tableware (Monograms, Logos, Maker Marks plus History).
I've only just scanned the book, but one thing is immediately evident: the work is not "scholarly." However, to the author's credit, he doesn't claim to be an "expert," even describing himself as a "rank amateur." I agree. He seems to have simply gathered up everything he could find and, uncritically, published a compilation.
I guess my question is, is anything in the book reliable? Or, conversely, are there any reliable references as to just what makers and patterns have been legitimately attributed to the Third Reich?
Ad blocker detected: Our website is made possible by displaying online advertisements to our visitors. Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker on our website.
Third Reich tableware
Do not post mark questions here.
-
- contributor
- Posts: 231
- Joined: Mon Sep 10, 2012 1:32 pm
- Location: Florida
Jump to
- The Silver Marks Forum ~ Requirements & Tutorials
- ↳ Posting Requirements
- Announcements
- ↳ Website Updates & Announcements
- American Sterling & Coin Silver - (no silverplate, jewelry or watches)
- ↳ Sterling Manufacturers ~ American after-1860
- ↳ Coin Silversmiths ~ American pre-1860
- ↳ Arts & Crafts Smiths ~ American Handwrought after-1900
- ↳ American Sterling & Coin Silver - Single Image
- British Hallmarks - (no silverplate, jewelry or watches)
- ↳ London Hallmarks
- ↳ Birmingham Hallmarks
- ↳ Chester Hallmarks
- ↳ Exeter Hallmarks
- ↳ Newcastle Hallmarks
- ↳ Sheffield Hallmarks
- ↳ York Hallmarks
- ↳ Scottish Hallmarks
- ↳ Irish Hallmarks
- ↳ Provincial & Colonial Marks
- ↳ Grimwade's Biographies ~ Updates
- ↳ London Lost Registers & Unrecorded Marks
- ↳ British Hallmarks - Single Image
- European Silver - (no silverplate, jewelry or watches)
- ↳ Dutch Silver
- ↳ French Silver
- ↳ German Silver
- ↳ Russian Silver
- ↳ Scandinavian Silver
- ↳ Other Countries
- ↳ German, French, Dutch, Russian, Scandinavian or Other - Single Image
- Silverplated Ware
- ↳ Silverplate Trademarks - Worldwide
- ↳ Silver Plate Trademarks - Single Image
- Silver Jewelry & Watches
- ↳ American Jewelry
- ↳ European Jewelry
- ↳ Other Jewelry
- ↳ Silver Jewelry - Single Image
- Silver of the Americas
- ↳ Mexican Silversmiths
- ↳ Central & South America
- ↳ Native American Silver
- ↳ Silver of the Americas - Single Image
- Asian & Middle Eastern Silver
- ↳ Middle East
- ↳ Far East
- ↳ Asia & Middle East - Single Image
- Gold Marks
- ↳ Gold Marks - Worldwide
- ↳ Gold - Single Image
- Miscellaneous Silver Subjects
- ↳ General Questions
- ↳ Contributors' Notes
- ↳ Ephemera
- ↳ Silver Care / Techniques
- ↳ Mystery Objects
- ↳ Flatware Pattern Identification
- ↳ Family Crests
- ↳ Museum Exhibitions - Silver - Temporary
- ↳ Museum Exhibitions - Silver - Permanent